The new research shows that humans can perceive minute differences in the intensity of light but that this sensitivity is achieved at the cost of the ability to detect light particles.
For nearly one hundred years, neuroscientists have pondered whether the human eye could distinguish an individual light particle, known as a photon, which is the smallest possible quantity of light. This question has been difficult to answer because it was previously impossible to accurately reconcile human visual perception and retinal activity at the extreme sensitivity conditions in darkness.
Research conducted at the University of Helsinki reveals that the human visual system sacrifices the ability to detect individual photons in order to gain greater fidelity in detecting faint lights. The research findings challenge previous conceptions of how the visual system works.
“This research is a major step forward in visual neuroscience, providing new insight into how the human visual system functions under extreme conditions in darkness. Our study shows that the sensitivity of the human eye approaches the fundamental limits of physics, and the entire visual system performs at the absolute threshold of its capacity,” says Professor Petri Ala-Laurila who led the study. He runs his two laboratories at the Faculty of Biological and Environmental Sciences at Helsinki University and at the department of Neuroscience and Biomedical Engineering at Aalto University in Finland.
“Our research shows that the human visual system has evolved to detect faint contrasts with extreme precision, which has apparently been more important than detecting individual light particles,” says Dr Markku Kilpeläinen from the University of Helsinki’s Department of Psychology, the first author of the article.
Visual perception at the edge of darkness
The research showed that humans can detect extremely small differences in the intensity of light at the threshold of darkness. This precision is achieved thanks to the visual system’s highly effective ability to eliminate what is known as neural noise. However, this means that the visual system sacrifices the ability to detect individual photons.
The researchers took accurate electrophysiological measurements of the retina and conducted observational psychological tests measuring the activity of the visual system under identical conditions at the absolute threshold of perception. This allowed them to directly connect the person’s conscious visual perception to the activity of certain neurons in the retina for the first time.
“Above all, we were able to show that certain types of output neurons in the retina, known as retinal ON ganglion cells, are responsible for encoding faint light increments. This result reveals the exact division of responsibilities within the retina during a single visual task,” summarizes Professor Ala-Laurila.
Implications for the development of retinal prostheses
Eye diseases typically cause changes in the neural substrate and function of the retina. Understanding how particular retinal cell types participate in encoding visual information helps to design more effective treatment methods. The results of this research could help improve the detection and diagnosis of certain visual impairments and lay the foundations for understanding how the brain interprets the retinal code across specific cell types. This knowledge will greatly benefit developers of retinal prostheses.
Original article:
Kilpeläinen, M., Westö, J., Tiihonen, J. et al. Primate retina trades single-photon detection for high-fidelity contrast encoding. Nat Commun 15, 4501 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-48750-y
- What are retinal ganglion cells? Retinal ganglion cells are retinal neurons that transmit visual information to the brain in the form of nerve impulses known as action potentials. There are a few dozen different types of them. Before the ganglion cells transmit visual information to the brain, the network of retinal neurons performs a range of fascinating neural calculations on the distribution of photons entering the eye.
- What is neural noise? Neural noise is a phenomenon that occurs in the brain and nerve cells. It refers to random, unpredictable “disruptions” that occur in the activity and communication of nerve cells. Researchers are interested in neural noise because it could help them understand how these unavoidable disruptions impose constraints on the brain’s performance and how the nervous system has evolved over time to minimize these disruptions.