Dr. Lucia Cerullo is an archaeologist and art historian with a PhD in Asia, Africa, and the Mediterraneum from the University of Naples “L’Orientale”, in Italy. Her academic path began with a focus on Elamite epigraphy, explored in her Bachelor’s thesis on royal inscriptions from Persepolis. Over time, she developed a dual focus in archaeology and epigraphy, which she sees as essential in fully understanding ancient cultures. She has worked as an archaeologist in Italy, and held senior roles in fieldwork across Uzbekistan and Iran, including nearly seven years at the Iran National Museum in Tehran. Her expertise focuses on 1st Millenium BCE material culture, especially metal objects and pottery.
Can you tell us something about the book to start off?
It is a catalogue of metal vessels that focuses on three collections: Arǧān, Ǧūbaǧī, and Kalmākarrah. Two of them are burials, Arǧān and Ǧūbaǧī, while Kalmākarrah is a hoard, or treasure, found inside a cave. The descriptions of the collections include the problems they present, a bit of research history, and the discovery context.
With Arǧān and Ǧūbaǧī, we are working in a burial context. The idea is that all burials include a standard kit of tableware, food, or figurines placed inside the tomb. The vessels were intended both for the deceased and the people performing the funerary ritual banquet, Kispu. The ritual probably occurred every year, when the deceased's family or relatives went to the tomb to drink and eat in their honour. This is what we can reconstruct.
Several hypotheses try to explain the Kalmākarrah deposit: why were so many objects placed inside a cave? Some scholars suspect the cave protected silver and gold objects from local or enemy incursions, whereas others link it to religion or see it as a kind of favissa, a Roman term for a pit where votive offerings to the gods were stored. We do not know exactly what it was, and forgeries and a lack of archaeological context further complicate the question.
As for the Kalmākarrah objects' origin, we have only word of mouth. The local people took objects from the cave and began selling them, and over the years, the only evidence of their origin has been people’s testimony that they really came from the Kalmākarrah cave. The cave was never excavated. Locals contacted the authorities only long after taking the objects, and by then they had already spread widely. This is why alleged Kalmakarra objects can now be found in Tokyo, in Dubai, and elsewhere.
This is one of the things I am trying to address; even though we stress so strongly that archaeological context matters, as it is the only concrete evidence we can use, it is still important to study unprovenanced objects.
In the catalogue, I try to reconstruct each object’s life cycle, starting with the raw material: where it was procured and how the metal was smelted and refined. This covers the metal industries and workshop practices, even though we have little archaeological context for workshops. Then I turn to the craftsmen: what we know generally about who made such objects (not this particular one, since it would be impossible to know). After that comes the administrative evidence for metal production, the archaeometallurgical analysis, and the technical investigation, which tell us more about the object’s intrinsic characteristics.
What are the tombs of Arǧān and Ǧūbaǧī like?
Excavations uncovered two tombs in different areas within the same region. The remains in Arǧān probably belong to a local ruler, Kidin-Hutran, son of Kurluš, since four inscribed objects bear his name. The Ǧūbaǧī is more complicated, but we believe the remains belong to two women. We have four inscriptions on four different objects, and they all say something different. One inscription names Shutur-Nahunte, son of Indada, so these two women were most likely related to his house, but that’s all we can get from it.
Although the Arǧān tomb was discovered in 1982 and discussed in several papers and books, it still offers much new information. One example from my research illustrates the importance of bringing different sources into dialogue. Comparing the excavation plans with early photographs, I noticed that part of the original assemblage had been overlooked in the scholarship I consulted. Contemporary Persian-language records provided further information. This highlighted how sources in different languages can preserve information essential to reconstructing the archaeological record.
I have also added further material to the book, including the inscriptions and my own drawings, which are essential. A full overview of the objects, along with an understanding of their physical characteristics and properties, matters a great deal. For example, we need to know the metal profile's thickness to understand how the craftsmen worked the material.
Your work sometimes features intricate archaeological drawings made by you. Do you have a set way of going about starting or finishing a drawing?
Yes, that is something they teach us during our Archaeology studies. You need to understand the wall thickness, and to do that, you need tools to measure it accurately. Here [shows a picture], I was lucky because the object is complete, but if you have a fragment, you need to determine which part of the vessel it comes from, because the method differs whether it's from the lip or the base. Then you need to determine the object's inclination, because it affects the result. You must be careful not to tilt the lip upwards; otherwise, the whole shape of the vessel will change. And then you need the height and the diameter.
Once you have these three points, you can put them together and proceed step by step. You might also use a profilometer, a soft instrument you press against the vessel's wall, which you can then recreate on paper. You won't do all of these steps every time, but this is the main process. To put the whole picture together, you need all the measurements, including the vessel's largest circumference, mouth diameter, base diameter, and height. When you are able to view the object from 360 degrees, you can determine what is relevant to include in the drawing.
How did you end up focusing on these three collections? Is there something that connects them besides the fact that two of them are burials?
I have brought together the same types of materials, so metal vessels, from three contexts: the two tombs and Kalmākarrah. The two tombs, in particular, contain vessels of similar shapes, and all three contexts share the same kind of Neo-Elamite inscriptions. I wanted to record a similar pattern across the three contexts, and I see it clearly in the two tombs, whereas Kalmākarrah is more difficult.
Some studies suggest that the Kalmākarrah objects are examples of material acculturation, reflecting a mixing of traditions. The Lobed plate with the animal that I showed is a good example, since its shape recurs in the Achaemenid period. We are talking about a span of two or three centuries, and Kalmākarrah may well be somewhat later. Still, the contexts are linked on several levels, geographical, epigraphical, chronological, and material, and most of the objects are bronze and silver.
Have you seen these objects in real life and worked with them?
Yes. I started this project as my MA thesis. It was a broad concept centred on Susa and the surrounding region. Since we have an epigraphical archive from Susa attesting to the movement of metals and metal objects, I wanted to see what we have archaeologically from the New Elamite period (late 7th and 6th centuries BC). Moving from the Middle Elamite period, a time of great creativity, to the New Elamite period, the record shows a significant gap. Unfortunately, the tablets are our only attestations of metal production from that time. We also don’t have as many objects from that period as from the Middle Elamite period. Because of that, I focus mostly on these objects.
I was able to go to the National Museum of Tehran and work directly with the objects because my former university had a memorandum of understanding with the museum. I started with these three case studies, and yes, I handled, photographed, drew, and measured all of them.
I was really lucky to spend my time there. They also let me carry out some metallurgical analysis on a few objects, very few, because that kind of research destroys the object. You can take a piece out, but that piece will be destroyed. From the analysis, I gained more information about the metal composition and the techniques used. This adds value to what was published before.
One important point about working with material objects is that you cannot base your research solely on photographs or other people’s descriptions. Their only aim is to show you the object, not its properties. For example, these plates are from Kalmākarrah (The Lobed plates 1, 2 & 4), and as you can see, they have an animal’s head engraved inside, under the rim. Other photographs have never shown this. Seeing it and working with it in person gives you more information. It could be an artisan’s mark or a status symbol for the plate’s owner. You can't learn much from a photo alone.
You mentioned that you've done your master's on the same topic and then a PhD, and now this... How did you come to research this specific topic about these vessels?
[During my MA] I was interested in Elamite culture and its metal material culture, and I wanted to try something different. The main problem with this material is access, so I first asked my professors whether I could go to Iran, and luckily they said yes. I wanted to learn more about the objects themselves, including their materials, because they show what kinds of metal were moving through the area at the time. An object can tell you so much. It can reveal production techniques, workers' skills, and the kinds of labour present in the region. It can also show cultural links between, for example, Iran, Assyria, and the Levant, and suggest how objects, or even craftsmen, circulated, so production was no longer regional but broader. And of course it speaks to wealth: here we have two very rich tombs, which we can connect to a wealthy family or individual.
Kalmākarrah is different because of its unanswered questions. Why would silver objects be stored in a cave in a mountain with nothing around? Luckily, a closer look at the objects gives us a lot of information. Some of the vessels bear the name of the Samati people. We don't know who they were, but a tablet from Susa from roughly the same period also mentions them, so we know they existed and probably had some commercial interaction with the main city of Elam. That raises the question of why they held so many silver objects, which are clear symbols of high status. No other references to these people are known, which is frustrating, but the inscriptions name several individuals, so you can reconstruct a sort of ruling family. I say that carefully because the period was one of fragmented power, and we cannot assume these were kings in the sense they called themselves.
One of the cups has two inscriptions, written at different times, as the script and palaeography differ. The first gives the object's weight in shekels, and the second records a dedication by someone from Samati to the goddess Dilbat. So you can see the object change function: it was probably made as a precious object with a specified silver weight, then dedicated to a deity. Together, the inscriptions raise questions about how silver was used, its function, and the role of gift-giving to the king.
The lack of archaeological context makes all of this somewhat fuzzy, and many scholars are unwilling to engage with these objects for this reason. I wanted to try to add more information and produce something that helps answer our questions. As you can see, even material studied forty years ago can still give you something new.
This interview is part of WORK-IT’s ongoing project for our Brill book series.