Most people who ever lived were “bone crushingly poor,” says historian Anne McCants. Many lived in some form of bondage. Yet the history we know is largely the history of a privileged minority.
“What do we owe all these people?”
For McCants, the question goes to the heart of why she studies history. She has spent much of her career trying to recover lives that left little evidence behind, sometimes not even a name.
“The people we know about from history wanted dignity for themselves. Those we know nothing about surely wanted the same.”
But history matters to McCants for another reason, too: she finds it endlessly fascinating.
“You know, it's fascinating, it's horrifying, it is occasionally absolutely inspirational and uplifting. And these are your fellow people. Get to know them.”
Her curiosity has also led her into unexpected fields. Her career, she says, owes as much to chance encounters and a willingness to seize opportunities than to advance planning.
“I think every single really great thing I've done has been serendipitous.”
An unexpected career in history
McCants began her graduate studies in a PhD program in economics, but within three weeks she realized it was not a good fit.
“Oh my goodness, I am in the wrong place,” she recalls thinking.
Before switching to history, she completed the master's degree in economics within the same program. She then moved to the University of California, Berkeley, to pursue a PhD in history under Dutch economic historian Jan de Vries.
As it turned out, her economics training was exactly what she needed to specialize in economic history at Berkeley.
During her first year, de Vries sent her to Friesland to collect tax records. While there, she visited Amsterdam's archives and found intriguing material.
“And before I knew it, I had become a Dutch historian. But that wasn't premeditated.”
A historian open to surprises
Although McCants specializes in economic history, her interests extend to philosophy, theology, history of thought and disciplinary methods.
“I'm happy that my home discipline is history because it allows me to pursue a broader set of questions.”
Her research has taken her in many directions. In Amsterdam, she has used household inventories to investigate how ordinary people lived and what they owned in the eighteenth century. A chance conversation led to a ten-year research project on nineteenth-century railways in Portugal. Invited to join a project on the Cape Colony in South Africa, McCants brought experience with Dutch-language probate inventories but little knowledge of African history. She was surprised by how much the records could reveal.
“I was genuinely surprised, actually, at what the possibilities are.”
Her biggest surprise, however, began with a conversation after a conference talk in 2017 where she met Daniel Seligson, an MIT alumnus interested in polygamous marriage systems. That conversation eventually led to a research collaboration.
Their 2022 study examined the relationship between polygamy, women's status and economic development, including links to large age gaps between spouses, bride price and discrimination against women. According to McCants, their ongoing analyses suggest that marriage systems help explain differences in economic development between societies as or more strongly than factors such as colonialism, communism or climate.
“That I would say has been the single biggest surprise in my career.”
Studying cultural practices can raise difficult questions about how researchers interpret evidence and write about the societies they study.
“It's impossible to do history well without touching a nerve.”
Time to think and explore
McCants' path to Helsinki began with another chance encounter. During a visit to Finland for the 2022 Baltic Connections conference, she met a researcher on a museum tour who invited her to participate in a PhD summer school. The experience brought her back to Finland several times and eventually led to an invitation to spend a year as the Jane and Aatos Erkko Visiting Professor in Studies on Contemporary Society.
At the Helsinki Collegium for Advanced Studies, McCants enjoys a break from teaching and administration, giving her more time to concentrate on research.
“Part of it is just reducing the interruptions,” she says.
It is not just about having more time. McCants particularly enjoys the Collegium's sense of community. Researchers from different disciplines meet over lunch, share ideas and attend talks on subjects far removed from their own work.
“People are fascinating, they are a little more relaxed, the lunch conversations – you never know where they're going to go.”
The opportunity to learn from other researchers is particularly rewarding.
“I feel like a kid in a candy store.”